[TD-3963]alter db rpc return when vnode response

src/dnode/src/dnodeVMgmt.c

@@ -154,7 +154,6 @@ static SCreateVnodeMsg* dnodeParseVnodeMsg(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {
 
 static int32_t dnodeProcessCreateVnodeMsg(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {
   SCreateVnodeMsg *pCreate = dnodeParseVnodeMsg(rpcMsg);
-
   void *pVnode = vnodeAcquire(pCreate->cfg.vgId);
   if (pVnode != NULL) {
     dDebug("vgId:%d, already exist, return success", pCreate->cfg.vgId);

src/mnode/inc/mnodeVgroup.h

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ int32_t mnodeAddTableIntoVgroup(SVgObj *pVgroup, SCTableObj *pTable, bool needCh
 void    mnodeRemoveTableFromVgroup(SVgObj *pVgroup, SCTableObj *pTable);
 void    mnodeSendDropVnodeMsg(int32_t vgId, SRpcEpSet *epSet, void *ahandle);
 void    mnodeSendCreateVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, void *ahandle);
-void    mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup);
+void    mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup,SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
 void    mnodeSendSyncVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup);
 
 SRpcEpSet mnodeGetEpSetFromVgroup(SVgObj *pVgroup);

src/mnode/src/mnodeDb.c

@@ -24,12 +24,14 @@
 #include "tdataformat.h"
 #include "tp.h"
 #include "mnode.h"
+#include "dnode.h"
 #include "mnodeDef.h"
 #include "mnodeInt.h"
 #include "mnodeAcct.h"
 #include "mnodeDb.h"
 #include "mnodeDnode.h"
 #include "mnodeMnode.h"
+#include "mnodePeer.h"
 #include "mnodeProfile.h"
 #include "mnodeWrite.h"
 #include "mnodeSdb.h"
@@ -43,6 +45,8 @@ int64_t tsDbRid = -1;
 void *  tsDbSdb = NULL;
 static int32_t tsDbUpdateSize;
 
+#define ALTER_CDB_RETRY_TIMES  3
+
 static int32_t mnodeCreateDb(SAcctObj *pAcct, SCreateDbMsg *pCreate, SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
 static int32_t mnodeDropDb(SMnodeMsg *newMsg);
 static int32_t mnodeSetDbDropping(SDbObj *pDb);
@@ -51,6 +55,7 @@ static int32_t mnodeRetrieveDbs(SShowObj *pShow, char *data, int32_t rows, void
 static int32_t mnodeProcessCreateDbMsg(SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
 static int32_t mnodeProcessDropDbMsg(SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
 static int32_t mnodeProcessSyncDbMsg(SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
+static void mnodeProcessAlterDbRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg);
 int32_t mnodeProcessAlterDbMsg(SMnodeMsg *pMsg);
 
 #ifndef _TOPIC
@@ -198,6 +203,7 @@ int32_t mnodeInitDbs() {
   mnodeAddWriteMsgHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_CM_ALTER_DB, mnodeProcessAlterDbMsg);
   mnodeAddWriteMsgHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_CM_DROP_DB, mnodeProcessDropDbMsg);
   mnodeAddWriteMsgHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_CM_SYNC_DB, mnodeProcessSyncDbMsg);
+  mnodeAddPeerRspHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_CM_ALTER_DB_RSP, mnodeProcessAlterDbRsp);
   mnodeAddShowMetaHandle(TSDB_MGMT_TABLE_DB, mnodeGetDbMeta);
   mnodeAddShowRetrieveHandle(TSDB_MGMT_TABLE_DB, mnodeRetrieveDbs);
   mnodeAddShowFreeIterHandle(TSDB_MGMT_TABLE_DB, mnodeCancelGetNextDb);
@@ -1070,27 +1076,30 @@ static SDbCfg mnodeGetAlterDbOption(SDbObj *pDb, SAlterDbMsg *pAlter) {
   return newCfg;
 }
 
-static int32_t mnodeAlterDbCb(SMnodeMsg *pMsg, int32_t code) {
+static int32_t mnodeAlterDbFp(SMnodeMsg *pMsg) {
-  if (code != TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS) return code;
   SDbObj *pDb = pMsg->pDb;
 
   void *pIter = NULL;
   SVgObj *pVgroup = NULL;
-    while (1) {
+  while (1) {
     pIter = mnodeGetNextVgroup(pIter, &pVgroup);
     if (pVgroup == NULL) break;
     if (pVgroup->pDb == pDb) {
-      mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup);
+      mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup,pMsg);
+      pMsg->expected += 1;
     }
     mnodeDecVgroupRef(pVgroup);
   }
-
+  // in case there is no vnode(no db in vnode)
+  if (pMsg->expected == 0) {
+    return TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS;
+  }
   mDebug("db:%s, all vgroups is altered", pDb->name);
   mLInfo("db:%s, is alterd by %s", pDb->name, mnodeGetUserFromMsg(pMsg));
 
-  bnNotify();
+  //bnNotify();
 
-  return TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS;
+  return TSDB_CODE_MND_ACTION_IN_PROGRESS;
 }
 
 static int32_t mnodeAlterDb(SDbObj *pDb, SAlterDbMsg *pAlter, void *pMsg) {
@@ -1114,7 +1123,7 @@ static int32_t mnodeAlterDb(SDbObj *pDb, SAlterDbMsg *pAlter, void *pMsg) {
       .pTable  = tsDbSdb,
       .pObj    = pDb,
       .pMsg    = pMsg,
-      .fpRsp   = mnodeAlterDbCb
+      .fpReq   = mnodeAlterDbFp
     };
 
     code = sdbUpdateRow(&row);
@@ -1279,6 +1288,35 @@ void  mnodeDropAllDbs(SAcctObj *pAcct)  {
   mInfo("acct:%s, all dbs:%d is dropped from sdb", pAcct->user, numOfDbs);
 }
 
+static void mnodeProcessAlterDbRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {
+  if (rpcMsg->ahandle == NULL) return;
+
+  SMnodeMsg *pMsg = rpcMsg->ahandle;
+  pMsg->received++;
+
+  SDbObj *pDb = (SDbObj *)pMsg->pDb;
+  assert(pDb);
+
+  if (rpcMsg->code == TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS) {
+    mDebug("msg:%p, app:%p db:%s, altered in dnode, thandle:%p result:%s", pMsg, pMsg->rpcMsg.ahandle,
+           pDb->name, pMsg->rpcMsg.handle, tstrerror(rpcMsg->code));
+
+    dnodeSendRpcMWriteRsp(pMsg, TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS);
+  } else {
+    if (pMsg->retry++ < ALTER_CDB_RETRY_TIMES) {
+      mDebug("msg:%p, app:%p db:%s, alter table rsp received, need retry, times:%d result:%s thandle:%p",
+             pMsg->rpcMsg.ahandle, pMsg, pDb->name, pMsg->retry, tstrerror(rpcMsg->code),
+             pMsg->rpcMsg.handle);
+
+      dnodeDelayReprocessMWriteMsg(pMsg);
+    } else {
+      mError("msg:%p, app:%p db:%s, failed to alter in dnode, result:%s thandle:%p", pMsg, pMsg->rpcMsg.ahandle,
+             pDb->name, tstrerror(rpcMsg->code), pMsg->rpcMsg.handle);
+      dnodeSendRpcMWriteRsp(pMsg, rpcMsg->code);
+    }
+  }
+}
+
 int32_t mnodeCompactDbs() {
   void *pIter = NULL;
   SDbObj *pDb = NULL;

src/mnode/src/mnodeVgroup.c

@@ -60,7 +60,6 @@ static int32_t mnodeGetVgroupMeta(STableMetaMsg *pMeta, SShowObj *pShow, void *p
 static int32_t mnodeRetrieveVgroups(SShowObj *pShow, char *data, int32_t rows, void *pConn);
 static void    mnodeProcessCreateVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg);
 static void    mnodeProcessAlterVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg);
-static void    mnodeProcessSyncVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg);
 static void    mnodeProcessDropVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg);
 static int32_t mnodeProcessVnodeCfgMsg(SMnodeMsg *pMsg) ;
 static void    mnodeSendDropVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, void *ahandle);
@@ -237,7 +236,6 @@ int32_t mnodeInitVgroups() {
   mnodeAddShowFreeIterHandle(TSDB_MGMT_TABLE_VGROUP, mnodeCancelGetNextVgroup);
   mnodeAddPeerRspHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_MD_CREATE_VNODE_RSP, mnodeProcessCreateVnodeRsp);
   mnodeAddPeerRspHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_MD_ALTER_VNODE_RSP, mnodeProcessAlterVnodeRsp);
-  mnodeAddPeerRspHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_MD_ALTER_VNODE_RSP, mnodeProcessSyncVnodeRsp);
   mnodeAddPeerRspHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_MD_DROP_VNODE_RSP, mnodeProcessDropVnodeRsp);
   mnodeAddPeerMsgHandle(TSDB_MSG_TYPE_DM_CONFIG_VNODE, mnodeProcessVnodeCfgMsg);
 
@@ -271,7 +269,7 @@ void mnodeUpdateVgroup(SVgObj *pVgroup) {
   if (code != TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS && code != TSDB_CODE_MND_ACTION_IN_PROGRESS) {
     mError("vgId:%d, failed to update vgroup", pVgroup->vgId);
   }
-  mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup);
+  mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup,NULL);
 }
 
 /*
@@ -350,7 +348,7 @@ void mnodeUpdateVgroupStatus(SVgObj *pVgroup, SDnodeObj *pDnode, SVnodeLoad *pVl
     mError("dnode:%d, vgId:%d, vnode cfgVersion:%d:%d repica:%d not match with mnode cfgVersion:%d:%d replica:%d",
            pDnode->dnodeId, pVload->vgId, pVload->dbCfgVersion, pVload->vgCfgVersion, pVload->replica,
            pVgroup->pDb->dbCfgVersion, pVgroup->vgCfgVersion, pVgroup->numOfVnodes);
-    mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup);
+    mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(pVgroup,NULL);
   }
 }
 
@@ -946,10 +944,10 @@ SRpcEpSet mnodeGetEpSetFromIp(char *ep) {
   return epSet;
 }
 
-static void mnodeSendAlterVnodeMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, SRpcEpSet *epSet) {
+static void mnodeSendAlterVnodeMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, SRpcEpSet *epSet, SMnodeMsg *pMsg) {
   SAlterVnodeMsg *pAlter = mnodeBuildVnodeMsg(pVgroup);
   SRpcMsg rpcMsg = {
-    .ahandle = NULL,
+    .ahandle = pMsg,
     .pCont   = pAlter,
     .contLen = pAlter ? sizeof(SAlterVnodeMsg) : 0,
     .code    = 0,
@@ -958,14 +956,17 @@ static void mnodeSendAlterVnodeMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, SRpcEpSet *epSet) {
   dnodeSendMsgToDnode(epSet, &rpcMsg);
 }
 
-void mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup) {
+void mnodeSendAlterVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup,SMnodeMsg *pMsg) {
   mDebug("vgId:%d, send alter all vnodes msg, numOfVnodes:%d db:%s", pVgroup->vgId, pVgroup->numOfVnodes,
          pVgroup->dbName);
+  if (pMsg) {
+    pMsg->pVgroup = pVgroup;
+  }
   for (int32_t i = 0; i < pVgroup->numOfVnodes; ++i) {
     SRpcEpSet epSet = mnodeGetEpSetFromIp(pVgroup->vnodeGid[i].pDnode->dnodeEp);
     mDebug("vgId:%d, index:%d, send alter vnode msg to dnode %s", pVgroup->vgId, i,
            pVgroup->vnodeGid[i].pDnode->dnodeEp);
-    mnodeSendAlterVnodeMsg(pVgroup, &epSet);
+    mnodeSendAlterVnodeMsg(pVgroup, &epSet,pMsg);
   }
 }
 
@@ -1026,11 +1027,24 @@ void mnodeSendCreateVgroupMsg(SVgObj *pVgroup, void *ahandle) {
 }
 
 static void mnodeProcessAlterVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {
-  mDebug("alter vnode rsp received");
+  mDebug("alter vnode rsp is received, handle:%p", rpcMsg->ahandle);
-}
+  if (rpcMsg->ahandle == NULL) return;
 
-static void mnodeProcessSyncVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {
+  SMnodeMsg *mnodeMsg = rpcMsg->ahandle;
-  mDebug("sync vnode rsp received");
+  mnodeMsg->received++;
+  if (rpcMsg->code == TSDB_CODE_SUCCESS) {
+    mnodeMsg->code = rpcMsg->code;
+    mnodeMsg->successed++;
+  }
+
+  SVgObj *pVgroup = mnodeMsg->pVgroup;
+  mDebug("vgId:%d, alter vnode rsp received, result:%s received:%d successed:%d expected:%d, thandle:%p ahandle:%p",
+         pVgroup->vgId, tstrerror(rpcMsg->code), mnodeMsg->received, mnodeMsg->successed, mnodeMsg->expected,
+         mnodeMsg->rpcMsg.handle, rpcMsg->ahandle);
+
+  if (mnodeMsg->received != mnodeMsg->expected) return;
+
+  dnodeReprocessMWriteMsg(mnodeMsg);
 }
 
 static void mnodeProcessCreateVnodeRsp(SRpcMsg *rpcMsg) {

tests/pytest/alter/alter_keep.py

@@ -161,9 +161,9 @@ class TDTestCase:
 
         # the following line should generate an error, but the insert was a success
         # the time now-15d is out of range of now -10d 
-        tdSql.execute('insert into tb values (now-15d, 10)')
+        tdSql.error('insert into tb values (now-15d, 10)')
         tdSql.query('select * from tb')
-        tdSql.checkRows(rowNum + 1)
+        tdSql.checkRows(rowNum)
 
         # tdSql.execute('alter database db keep 20,20,20')
         # tdSql.query('show databases')